Molecular technologies used for the assessment of CH: a comparison of approaches
Droplet digital PCR | Whole exome next generation sequencing (NGS) | Targeted NGS | Targeted NGS with molecular barcodes | Targeted NGS with molecular inversion probes (MIPs) | |
Principle | Partitioning of single DNA templates into micro-droplets, followed by end-point PCRs and enumeration of fluorescent droplets | High-throughput sequencing of all coding regions from the human genome (ie, the exome) | High-throughput sequencing of selected exons and genes recurrently mutated in cancers (eg, myeloid neoplasms) | Short molecular barcode sequences are attached to DNA fragments during library construction; otherwise, similar to targeted NGS | MIPs, which carry tag sequences, are used to capture targeted DNA regions via hybridization prior to sequencing |
Comprehensiveness of testing; potential clinical/research uses | Low; suitable for small numbers of “hotspot” mutations | High; suitable for defining reference mutational landscapes of cancers | Moderate to high, depending on the panel; suitable for clinical testing or biomarker research once the recurrently mutated genes are known | ||
Barcoding/error correction | N/A | No | Yes | ||
Typical limit of detection | 0.01%–0.1% | As low as 2%–3% | <0.1% | ||
Amount of input DNA required | Low | Medium to high | Medium | ||
Samples per run | Variable, depending on number of tests and platform | Relatively few samples | More samples than WES | ||
Other consideration/ comments | Absolute quantification of VAFs | VAFs are approximate |
|
|
PCR-based testing, while analytically sensitive and inexpensive, is often restricted to the assessment of small numbers of ‘hotspot’ mutations. By contrast, sequencing in general allows for the more comprehensive evaluation of larger complements of mutations. Among sequencing approaches, WES, while comprehensive, is comparatively limited in terms of depths of coverage (limited analytical sensitivity) and the numbers of samples that can be sequenced at one time. The incorporation of molecular barcodes and similar tag sequences in some workflows allows for the distinction between low-level mutations and sequencing artefacts, thereby greatly improving the analytical sensitivity for low-level mutations.
MIPs, molecular inversion probes; NGS, next-generation sequencing; VAFs, variant allele fractions; WES, whole exome sequencing.